Vinebox vs Tasting Room Comparison 2022

About Vinebox  

Vinebox works with the philosophy that members should have control over what labels grace their wine rack. To this end, this unique club sends a set of glass-sized tasting vials of classic European reds and whites and, when you find one you like, sources a bottle and delivers it to your doorstep.

About Tasting Room  

Tasting Room adamantly steers clear of any palate profile technology because it firmly believes that, when it comes to wine preferences, nothing beats each member’s knowledge about their personal tastes and a one-to-one chat with an expert. Affordable, fine-quality labels hail from renowned regions.

Vinebox Main Benefits Overall 

The big calling card for Vinebox is how it puts members in command over what’s in their “cellars”. This is appealing for people who already know a little about their reds and whites and want to be selective about what’s in their glass. It’s also ideal for those who are new to wine as, from the get-go, you have the opportunity to try out and build on your tasting skills and learn about different grapes and styles in general, and your own tastes in particular.

The club is quarterly, and you accrue credits for full bottles with every shipment.

Tasting Room Main Benefits Overall 

If you want to leave consumer technology out of how you pick your Chardonnay and Merlot, you’ll love Tasting Room. There’s not a rubric or algorithm in sight and absolutely no questions about how you like your coffee and what your favorite citrus fruit is. What you get is a personal wine expert who gets to know what you like and guides you to the perfect bottle time after time.

You can pick and choose from several delivery frequencies and two different bottle counts depending on how much wine you like flowing into your home. The portfolio is stringently tried and tested.

Overall Winner

Tasting Room

Vinebox Wine Selection 

Vinebox is a valuable white wine club because it partners with small, dedicated producers primarily located in iconic European regions where there’s plenty of good Pinot Grigio, Sauvignon Blanc, and White Rioja. It has an equally eminent range of red wines touching on the unique regions and appellations of Europe. Reds and whites make up the mainstay of the portfolio but Vinebox will occasionally send a rosé for you to taste.

The club has tasted more than 11,000 wines and only selected a handful, so you know you’re getting fine quality. Tasting notes and food pairing tips accompany each taster.

Tasting Room Wine Selection 

Tasting Room is the consumer-facing part of an international collective of winemakers that supply the club with the finest, good-value labels from across the Old and New Worlds. With classic grapes and styles from iconic regions, if you’re looking for a good red wine club, you’ll find choice labels in its range.

A selection of exciting, carefully-crafted whites also feature in a portfolio that has garnered an average rating of 4.25 stars out of 5 from members. Since Tasting Room works directly with producers, subscribers benefit from up to 60% off retail prices.

Wine Selection Winner:

Vinebox and Tasting Room tie over their wine selections as each club offers good-value quality.

Vinebox Wine Subscription Plans 

When you sign up to Vinebox, you receive nine glass-sized servings of the season’s latest European wines every quarter. Each vial is 100ml which is ample enough for a good nose, swirl, and sip to assess the red or white and decide if you’d like a full bottle. It’s very important to note that the wines arrive as fresh as if you’d just cracked a bottle open.

Vinebox uses cutting-edge technology that seals in each taster so that its particular characteristics are preserved for your taste buds. You have the choice of advance quarterly or annual payment with the latter being a bit cheaper. There may be a waiting list.

Tasting Room Wine Subscription Plans 

With Tasting Room, you get a flexible choice of either six or 12 bottle counts and can choose from monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly shipping schedules. The selection in your case is based on conversations you have with your personal wine concierge about what you’d like and can include tried-and-tested favorites plus new styles and grapes you’re curious about.

At the end of the day, you decide with the guidance of a pro. You can change the shipping and bottle quantity details in between deliveries whenever it suits you. What’s more, you get to redeem $40 in savings on your first case which features six full bottles of wine.

Subscription Plans Winner:

Tasting Room

Vinebox Pricing and Shipping 

You have the choice of paying for Vinebox membership every quarter which is $79 or in advance for the entire year. If you go for the latter, the cost is $288 so you enjoy a saving. What’s more, as a loyalty thank you, when this annual subscription is ready for renewal, you have the choice of paying on a quarterly basis at a reduced rate of $72.

Want to double up on your shipments? Vinebox can arrange this for you and throw in a 10% discount to boot. Vinebox shipments arrive about five days after membership commencement or renewal. Delivery is free.

Tasting Room Pricing and Shipping 

There are two bottle count choices at Tasting Room; six bottles cost $75 while a dozen is $150. The bottom-line cost comes down to which frequency of delivery you’ve chosen. On top of the case cost, there’s tax and shipping charges, the latter being $20. Tasting Room uses reputable couriers like UPS and, once your order has left the warehouse and is on the road, you can track your order for greater convenience (so you know you can slip out for some bread and cheese!).

If you’ve put your order in and realize, you’d like to change the address for any reason, you can do so but only for one hour afterward.

Pricing and Shipping Winner:

Vinebox

Vinebox Customer Service and Guarantee 

The only ways of getting in touch with Vinebox are by email and social messaging. Vinebox invests a lot of time trying and sourcing labels in order to deliver top-quality, worthy finds to members. Since you taste before you buy, there should be no need to query full bottles since you’ve chosen them! However, if a label arrives damaged or compromised in some way, you can contact the club via email with a description of the problem and a photograph clearly displaying it. Vinebox will give you a refund or re-ship the damaged bottle at no charge.

Tasting Room Customer Service and Guarantee

You can reach Tasting Room by chat, drop-down customer support messaging, email, or mail. The club knows that everyone’s palate is different, so all bottles are backed by Tasting Room's “Total Satisfaction Guarantee”. If a bottle doesn’t come up to your expectations, the club will replace it or provide credit to put towards a favorite wine. If a bottle arrives in less than pristine condition, contact customer service and it will find an appropriate solution. It may be necessary to send a photo of the damage. You can also return a case, but it has to be unopened and there may be shipping fees. 

Customer Service and Guarantee Winner:

Tasting Room

Vinebox Cancellation Terms  

You can terminate your subscription at any time via email. However, if you’ve just paid your membership fee for an upcoming delivery, Vinebox can’t refund this. The cancellation will come into effect for the next planned shipment.

This applies to both the quarterly and annual plans so, for the latter, you’ll need to wait for the yearly cycle to end before any cancellation comes into being.If you need to skip a box, Vinebox is flexible. Get in touch and, as with cancelation, simply do it in a timely fashion.

Tasting Room Cancellation Terms  

You are free to cancel your Tasting Room subscription at any time without any penalty. It’s important to note that cancelation will stop any unprocessed orders but if renewal and payment have already gone through the club system, it can’t be stopped and will still ship.

Any termination will take effect for the next scheduled membership payment. To cancel, contact the club via its support page. If you simply want to delay your shipment, you can do so via your account by changing the date of the next delivery.

Cancellation Terms Winner:

Vinebox and Tasting Room are each reasonable about cancelation so it’s a tie.

Vinebox Wine Gifts 

Vinebox offers two good gift options that are an ideal way of remembering a special occasion. Firstly, you can send a loved one credit of up to $158 via email which covers the cost of two boxes over six months. Secondly, you have the choice of doubling the quantity for $288.

Wine credits will accrue for your friend or family members just like they would for a regular member. Your recipient also has the option of using credit to select gift options themselves. Send credit by email or in a physical box. Vinebox also offers corporate gift options.

Tasting Room Gifts 

Tasting Room has a top choice of gift options covering all tastes and needs. If you want to share the joy of membership, your loved one will receive personalized cases of wine delivered to their home. You can choose from a one, three, or six-month gift subscription depending on what your recipient will prefer. Prices start at $89 and go up to $350.

If you’d like your loved one to get to choose what they want, a gift card will do the trick with $25, $50, and $100 values available. For something in between, there are tasting sets and wine gift boxes featuring a beautiful range of labels.

Buy as a Gift Winner:

Tasting Room