Plonk vs Winc Comparison 2022

About Plonk

Plonk is a wine club that focuses entirely on small-production organic and biodynamic reds and whites. It works with family vintners all over the Old and New Worlds and has won more than a few accolades for its delicious, ground-breaking range that’s kind to your body and nature.

About Winc 

Winc was launched by two wine lovers and a sommelier in 2012 who wanted to spread the joy of artisanal Californian wineries to both connoisseurs and novices of the Golden State. Its range ventures out into much-loved world regions, but its mainstay is limited-edition and bespoke wines from California.

Plonk Main Benefits Overall 

The stand-out selling point for Plonk is its portfolio of wines made in sync with nature. Each bottle comes from a winery that practices organic or biodynamic production in the vineyard and winery.

Plonk has great flexibility with three membership options plus several delivery frequencies and bottle quantities that have all bases covered. On the red tape front, there’s good customer support, a satisfaction guarantee, and you can easily cancel anytime. Furthermore, the club has a few handy gift options if you want to impress a wine lover.

Winc Main Benefits Overall 

If you love all the reds and whites California has to offer, Winc is the perfect club for you. It’s renowned for its selection of boutique labels from hand-selected wineries dotted around the Golden State.

You don’t just have a choice of pre-existing labels; this club also works closely with its partner vintners to make reds, whites, and rosés that suit the tastes of its members to a T. It works in the same way with producers from other major wine regions so there’s plenty of variety. What’s more, it customizes your cases with a palate quiz. 

Overall Winner

Plonk

Plonk Wine Selection

Plonk is a top white wine club because of its links to classic world regions where Chardonnay, Pinot Gris, and Riesling flows. It has a selection of reds to match plus a choice of rosés and sparkling labels.

While it makes sure it brings you all the varietals you love, Plonk also ferrets around Hungry, Greece, and other countries that are slightly off the grid offering untapped grape varieties that deserve more fans. The entire range is organic and/ or biodynamic meaning no pesticides or herbicides in the vineyard and no winery additives. 

Winc Wine Selection 

Winc sources most of its selection from a web of top boutique California vintners which means you’ve got a great red wine club in your sights. It has a good range of fine Zinfandels and all the red blends the Golden State has built such a stellar reputation on.

There are also plenty of excellent white labels in the range too with local expressions of international varietals. Winc also has its share of bubblies and a good choice of vegan, natural, low-alcohol/ sugar, and organic bottles. It regularly refreshes its range to keep things interesting.

Wine Selection Winner:

Both clubs offer exceptional ranges so it’s a draw.

Plonk Subscription Plans

Plonk has a convenient choice of memberships, bottle counts, and delivery frequencies covering all tastes and lifestyles. You can go for a case full of reds, whites, or mixed with the latter featuring rosé and sparkling wines too. Whichever subscription plan you choose, you can expect your case to be filled with both domestic and international labels.

There’s a choice of monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly subscriptions and you can pay month to month or in advance. You also can pick four, six, or 12 bottles per shipment. If you ever want to stock up on a few more labels you’ve enjoyed, you can do so with an extra order of a minimum of six bottles.

Winc Subscription Plans 

Once signed up for Winc membership, you pay $59.95 each month which is converted into credits you cash in for wine. Each dollar equals one credit, and you have to exchange them for your choice of reds and whites each month.

Winc will customize your cases by sending you recommendations of labels you’ll enjoy based on the club palate quiz you took on joining up the club. There’s the chance to build up credits by referring a friend to the club and you can use these to pay your monthly fee or shop in Winc’s store.

Subscription Plans Winner:

Plonk

Plonk Pricing and Shipping

There’s a flat rate regardless of whether you go for the red, white, or a mixed case and the cost is per case (not per month unless you choose the monthly delivery plan). Four wines cost $110 per shipment, six bottles are $160, and a dozen are charged at $285. Shipping is free for all membership types and levels.

In the event of very bad weather, Plonk may hold off delivery for a few days until conditions improve. Wines are shipped the first week of every month and take between five and ten days to arrive. Plonk can reroute after shipping if necessary, for a charge of $20.

Winc Pricing and Shipping 

As outlined above, Winc’s monthly fee is $59.95 which you cash in for three or four wines that suit you. There are some good wine club deals too. For your first order, you enjoy a “welcome gift” $20 discount and, whenever you order up to 12 bottles from Winc’s store, you’re entitled to 10% off.

Shipping costs are not added on any orders of $50 or more which ties in nicely with the monthly subscription fee. Winc offers expedited shipping if you need your bottles urgently. There are two options comprising overnight delivery if you’re in a real rush or a two-day delivery window when you can wait a little but still need your labels asap.

Pricing and Shipping Winner:

It’s another tie as both clubs come up trumps on shipping.

Plonk Customer Service and Guarantee

To get in touch with Plonk, there are two choices; phone during office hours or email. This club is very conscientious about responding in a timely manner, so you never get frustrated about customer service.

As far as a guarantee goes, the Plonk tasting team tries countless wines in its search for the finest and most interesting organic and biodynamic labels and only passes a small number, so I’d be surprised if one of your bottles isn’t up to par. That being said, Plonk’s satisfaction guarantee is spotless. If you receive a bottle that’s damaged or you don’t like, get in touch within 72 hours and it’ll make you whole. 

Winc Customer Service and Guarantee

There are several convenient ways you can contact Winc. You have the choice of live chat and text during office hours and email which the club will aim to respond to within 24 hours.

The club has a phone line, but it isn’t always available in difficult circumstances (like a pandemic). The club is dedicated to customer satisfaction, so if any of your labels don’t float your boat for any reason, contact Winc and its customer service team will try to fix the problem. This normally means crediting you with the full value of the rogue bottle/s.

Customer Service and Guarantee Winner:

Winc

Plonk Cancellation Terms  

Whether you can cancel or not depends on what plan you have with Plonk. If you’ve prepaid for subscriptions with a duration of three, six, or 12 months you’re not entitled to a cancelation refund as they’re classed as “non-refundable final sales”.

On the other hand, if you pay for your membership plan on a rolling monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly basis, you can cancel when you want. For it to take effect before your next shipment, you need to do the deed in your account or contact Plonk at least seven working days before your next scheduled billing date.

Winc Cancellation Terms  

Canceling your Winc membership is straightforward. You get in touch with the club through phone or email and inform it about our decision to process the cancelation. The customer service team will want to check if there’s any way the club can be more enjoyable for you and guide you to a few options that could improve your experience. The bottom line though is, if you’re ready to close your membership, Winc will facilitate this for you. It’s worth noting that if you’re on the fence about outright cancelation, you can skip a month indefinitely without any penalty.

Cancellation Terms Winner:

Winc

Plonk Gifts 

If you’re enthusiastic about the range of healthy, fine, and interesting wines Plonk sends you, there’s the option of giving a loved one gift membership. Anyone who loves their reds and whites will truly appreciate such a gift. You simply purchase a gift subscription for your friend or family member and they just sit back and wait for the gem-filled cases to arrive.

You buy the gift membership via your own account and select the “gift” option using your recipient’s address for shipments. For convenience, there’s the choice of sending the gift message via email. For a more personal touch, the club will send you a printable gift announcement you can present yourself.

Winc Gifts 

Surely you know a friend or family member who’d enjoy a taste of Californian artisanal wine in all its glory. A Winc membership is ideal for oenophiles and it takes the pain out of thinking of a gift. How it works is you purchase a gift card charged with from $60 to $600 and send it to your recipient.

The lucky recipient can use the credit to purchase at least one month of Winc membership or go on a shopping spree in the club store. There’s a handy email gift card or personal postal option. 

Buy as a Gift Winner:

Plonk and Winc are neck-on-neck for gift choices.