Plonk vs WSJ Wine Club Comparison 2022

About Plonk

Plonk’s raison d’être is bringing small-production organic and biodynamic reds and whites from across Old and New World regions to its subscribers.

Owner Etty Klein has been in the spotlight more than a few times thanks to her ground-breaking range that’s kind to both your body and the environment.

About WSJ Wine Club

WSJ Wine Club was the first on the 12-bottle delivery scene and, as such, has a fine network of vintners at its fingertips.

It’s all about giving you the finest labels from a network of A-list producers without breaking the bank. Its calling card is award winning labels and top-rated bottles.

Plonk Main Benefits Overall 

The stellar feature of Plonk is its selection of wines made with nature in mind. Each red and white hails from a vigneron who practices organic and/or biodynamic farming in the vineyard and continues such care in the winery. There are no synthetic chemicals used anywhere throughout production.

Plonk offers a good choice with three subscription plans as well as several delivery frequencies and bottle quantity options. There’s a satisfaction guarantee and a range of gifts for fellow wine lovers.

WSJ Wine Club Main Benefits Overall 

If you want labels that have been tried and tested by top critics and given a glowing report, WSJ Wine Club is for you. Owing to its sound network of class-act wineries built up since it launched in 2008, you get the finest reds and whites at wallet-friendly prices.

There’s a great introductory offer, a choice of two exceptional memberships, a satisfaction guarantee, and solid customer service. What’s more, if you’re looking for a gift for a fellow wine lover, you’ll find a suitable option here.

Overall Winner

Right now, it’s a matter of so far, so good with Plonk and WSJ Wine Club.

Plonk Wine Selection

If you have a soft spot for all the wonderful white varieties out there, Plonk is perfect because it has an excellent white wine club range. It collaborates closely with vintners crafting organic Chardonnay, Albariño, and Riesling and, to keep your palate happy, untapped white grapes from undiscovered regions.

It also has an equally splendid selection of reds plus rosés and sparkling hand-crafted labels from around the globe.

WSJ Wine Club Wine Selection 

WSJ Wine Club is a top red wine club so if you have a weakness for Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, and Malbec, you’re in good company. Each of its labels is repeatedly highly rated by the club’s own members or has proven itself at international competitions so can be sure of consistent quality.

Its  whites shine just as brightly for the same reasons plus the club is always on the lookout for next star wine - and usually find it!

Wine Selection Winner:

Both clubs have different approaches but offer fine ranges so it’s a tie.

Plonk Subscription Plans

Plonk offers a flexible range of subscription plans, bottle counts, and shipping frequencies that covers all possible member needs and wants. You have a pick of monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly subscriptions and you can pay in advance or shipment to shipment.

There’s also a range of four, six, or 12 bottles per delivery and, what’s more, you can choose a case full of reds, whites, or mixed with the last option featuring the odd rosé and sparkling wines too. 

WSJ Wine Club Subscription Plans 

When you get on board WSJ Wine Club, you receive a welcome shipment of a dozen fine-quality bottles for $69.99. This gives you an idea of the good standard of quality ahead. After this, you can join The Discovery Club which is filled with labels that receive consistently high ratings from fellow members.

Alternatively, there’s The Premier Club which comprises shipments bursting with exceptional limited-edition and prize-winning bottles. You can opt for red, white, or mixed cases.

Subscription Plans Winner:

Plonk

Plonk Pricing and Shipping

Regardless of whether you go for the red, white, or a mixed case there’s a flat rate per shipment rather than for frequency. It all depends on the bottle count. Four wines cost  $110 per shipment, six bottles are $160, and a dozen are charged at $285.

Shipping is free for all subscription types, bottle quantities, and delivery frequencies. Wines are sent the first week of each month, taking between five and ten days to arrive.

WSJ Wine Club Pricing and Shipping 

As already mentioned, there are two memberships. The Discovery Club is $159.99 for 12 bottles every three months and The Premier club is $259.99 for the same bottle count frequency.

There’s a sales tax on top of this plus a $19.99 shipping fee (which isn’t too bad when you think of how heavy a case of a dozen bottles of wine is).

Pricing and Shipping Winner:

It’s another draw as both clubs come up trumps on shipping.

Plonk Customer Service and Guarantee

If you need to get in touch with Plonk, there are two ways of doing so; call during office hours or email. This club is conscientious about responding in a timely manner, so won’t feel frustrated with sub-par service.

As far as a satisfaction guarantee is concerned, if a bottle is damaged or you’re not keen on it, get in touch within 72 hours and Plonk will find a solution. 

WSJ Wine Club Customer Service and Guarantee

You can contact WSJ Wine via live chat during extended office hours during the week as well as email and mail. You can also keep in touch with a concierge team by phone.

WSJ Wine has a solid satisfaction guarantee in place, refunding or replacing a wine if a bottle isn’t your thing or arrives compromised, no questions asked. 

Customer Service and Guarantee Winner:

Both deliver their best for customers on both points so it’s a tie.

Plonk Cancellation Terms  

If you’ve prepaid for subscriptions whatever the bottle count or duration, you can’t get a refund because pre-pays are classed as “non-refundable final sales”.

However, if you have a rolling monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly basis plan, you can cancel anytime as long as you contact Plonk no less than a week before your next scheduled date for billing.

WSJ Wine Club Cancellation Terms  

WSJ Wine lets you cancel at any time if you decide it’s not the club for you. It also gives you two to three weeks’ advance notice of your next shipping date.

This is a very convenient reminder if you need to skip or delay a delivery for any reason, such as being away from home or need to finish your last selection of wine.

Cancellation Terms Winner:

WSJ Wine

Plonk Gifts 

If you enjoy Plonk’s fine organic labels and know someone else who will as well, you can buy them a gift membership for that special occasion. Access your account, choose the “gift” option inputting your loved one’s address for shipments, and their present will be on its way.

There’s the option of sending a gift message via your recipient’s email or Plonk will email you a gift announcement to print  and present yourself.

WSJ Wine Club Gifts 

The membership plans offered by WSJ Wine are really something to enthuse about . If you know a vino lover who has the same fine taste you do, you can make a gift of what the club has to offer.

You can place gift orders easily for friends and family easily via your club account. Just make sure you enter your recipient’s shipping details! 

Buy as a Gift Winner:

Plonk