Naked Wines vs Winc Comparison 2022

About Naked Wines

Naked Wines was founded in 2008 in the UK where it’s garnered 200,000 subscribers and then spread to the US where it has 100,000 subscribers. Members are called “angels” because they invest their fees into amazing small-scale winemaking and get to taste the finished products. About $3 million per month is invested.

About Winc  

Winc was started by two wine lovers and a sommelier who all had one thing in common: a passion for artisanal Californian wine. With their club, they share the joy with fellow fans who also have a special appreciation for Golden State wine. Winc’s portfolio also includes labels from other world regions.

Naked Wines Main Benefits Overall

Naked Wines offers a very unique membership choice where you invest your fees into artisanal winemaking then get the results delivered to your doorstep. As the club has a direct partnership with about 150 vintners across the Old and New Worlds and gives the middleman a wide berth, you enjoy up to 60% in savings.

As well as you enjoying one-off, limited-edition labels at such good prices, vintners get the support they need to do amazing things and, without your help, they probably would struggle to. You also have the chance to keep in touch with favorite winemakers via designated message areas.

Winc Main Benefits Overall 

Winc is the leader of the pack when it comes to boutique wines from California. It has recognized the great winemaking happening on its doorstep and showcases it for existing fans of the state and those who are new to the regions and interested in exploring its fruits.

While Californian reds and whites are its mainstays, it also has a tranche dedicated to bottles from other iconic world regions in Europe and South America. It works with all its partners in the same way: sourcing the best they have to offer and commissioning new wines with member tastes in mind.

Overall Winner

Naked Wines

Naked Wines Wine Selection 

Given its global reach, Naked Wines is a top white wine club but also has its share of reds, rosés, and fizz from across Old and New World regions. You can bank on funding projects that cover your favorites grapes and styles. In touch with consumer tastes, it also has a range of organic labels, and its range features dessert and fortified bottles.

It has its fingers in 76 regions in 12 countries bringing you 59 grape varietals as well as blends. When you order, you get choices on alcohol percentage and dietary requirements too.

Winc Wine Selection 

With the lion’s share of Winc’s splendid range coming from Californian, you can expect it to be a great red wine club but also has an ample range of whites, rosés, and bubbly labels as well.

Classic popular varieties like Chardonnay and Zinfandel have pride of place in its portfolio but it also boasts a range of grapes all made with the special Californian microclimates in mind.If you’re health and environmentally conscious, you have the option of picking and choosing from a range of vegan, organic, natural, low-sugar/ alcohol labels as well.

Wine Selection Winner:

Naked Wines

Naked Wines Wine Subscription Plans 

As a member of Naked Wines, you deposit $40 into your club “piggy bank” every month and cash it in when you want on all the amazing artisanal labels in this club’s range. You can sign up for $100 off your first shipment and Naked Wines throws in a bottle of complimentary wine to thank you for your support.

If you have a month or two where you don’t feel like ordering any bottles, that’s no problem. You convert your investment into wines when it suits you. Your subscription is rolling and you’re in control of how you use it.

Winc Wine Subscription Plans 

With a Winc subscription, you get your deliveries on a monthly basis with three or four in each case. When you hit four bottles or more, shipping is included. If you find more wine is arriving than you can handle, you have the option of skipping a delivery so long as you let Winc know 48 hours in advance.

What’s more, you can use this facility for as long as you want without any penalty being incurred. After all, you never know when you’re going to be away from home longer than expected and don’t want a case of wine sitting on your doorstep.

Subscription Plans Winner:

Both Naked Wines and Winc offer good perks and flexibility so it’s hard to choose one over the other here.

Naked Wines Pricing and Shipping 

With Naked Wines, the more you order, the better the savings. Shipping is undertaken by pros companies UPS, GSO or FedEx so you can be confident that your bottles will be carefully packaged up for transport. If you spend up to $100, there’s a charge of $9.99.

If you go above this, delivery is included in the cost of your wine with the exception of Hawaii and Alaska where there is no delivery included. The cost here is $130 and $70 per package respectively. There’s a facility to track your order and request changes to your delivery.

Winc Pricing and Shipping 

Your membership fee is $59.95 every month and you cash this in for different styles of wines. With your first delivery, you enjoy a $20 discount. In each shipment, you get three to four bottles and if you order 12 or more, you get 10% off so full that wine rack!There’s no shipping cost if you have four or more bottles sent in any given delivery – another reason to stock up.

For a fee, you can also take advantage of extra shipping choices like overnight delivery if you need your wine in a hurry or a 2-day option if you’ve got a little time to spare.

Pricing and Shipping Winner:

Winc

Naked Wines Customer Service and Guarantee 

You can get in touch with Naked Wines by phone, live automated chat, and email. If you use the latter, the club tries to reply within 24 hours Monday to Friday. If you aren’t satisfied with a wine – whether it’s not your thing or it’s corked or damaged – you can call the club and they’ll give you a full refund. You can also express your option with a thumbs up or down about your labels via a personal dedicated rating page. If you downrate a bottle, Naked Wines makes a note and steers you clear of similar wines.

Winc Customer Service and Guarantee

Winc offers the standard ways of getting in touch with live chat and phone during office hours plus email. The club is dedicated to customer satisfaction so if something isn’t quite right for you, contact Winc and it’ll sort out the problem whether it’s down to wine damage or a label simply isn’t your taste. How it works is Winc will give you credit for the problem label for you to use towards a bottle that suits your preferences. What’s more, its concierge team will discuss what you like to help you pick bottles that you’ll get 100% enjoyment from.

Customer Service and Guarantee Winner:

Winc and Naked Wines draw on this one as they both put a lot into customer satisfaction.

Naked Wines Cancellation Terms  

Canceling your Naked Wines subscription is very simple: you can call its customer service line or email the club clearly stating you’d like to end your membership and any outstanding credit you have in your account will be returned. Naked Wines will likely check why you want to leave as it may be a matter of you not using your membership to your best advantage.

It’ll point out the huge discount on market prices, its no-quibble guarantee, and the freedom you have to spend your investment as you wish. Still, if you’ve made up your mind, cancellation is straightforward.

Winc Cancellation Terms  

Cancelling your Winc membership couldn’t be simpler. You can do so by using one of its contact options (phone, chat, or email). The team at customer service will bring your attention to options that might be better for you to use than outright canceling.  These include the month skipping option that can continue for as long as you wish.

If it’s just a matter of canceling a case rather than your subscription, Winc will do its best even if the shipment is already on its way. If you really are ready to say goodbye to Winc, cancellation is easy.

Cancellation Terms Winner:

Again, both clubs offer customer-centric cancelation options, so both come out ahead.

Naked Wines Wine Gifts 

Unfortunately, it doesn’t look as if this club offers gift memberships directly. However Naked Wines has a special section for options where you’ll find service accessories, chic wine packs, and gift cards in $100, $50, $20, and $10 multiples to give to loved ones. If you want to mix and match labels yourself for a super-personalized gift case, there’s a great selection of bottles to choose from.

What’s more, if you want to get particularly personal, contact Naked Wines and it can create a gift package that’s tailored to your loved one.

Winc Gifts 

If you just know your best friend or one of your aunts or cousins will just love a taste of Californian wine, there are a couple of ways you can make a present of all Winc has to offer. This club has a gift card option with some flexibility about how much cash you top it up with.

If it meets the monthly membership fee, the recipient can use the card to try Winc out or, if club membership doesn’t float their boat, they can cash the card in to oared some of tix club’s splendid wines. As a bonus, you can send cards electronically or by mail!

Buy as a Gift Winner:

Winc