Naked Wines vs Firstleaf Comparison 2022

Our wine club reviews, focus on all of the key features of different well-known names and highlight how each compares with the other. Once you’ve read through this club comparison, you’ll know which is the best wine club for your tastes.

Naked Wines vs Firstleaf Comparison

About Naked Wines

Naked Wines was launched in the UK in 2008 where it boasts 200,000 members. News spread fast and it opened in the US as well where it has a membership of 100,000. Subscribers are called “angels'' and owing to the fact that they make wine making dreams come true by investing their fees into fresh projects across the world.

nakedwines

About Firstleaf

Oenophile Philip James started Firstleaf with the aim of putting the customer fair-and-square in the center with its own palate tasting technology (for which it has a patent-pending). This cutting-edge technology matches your preferences with its first-class range of labels. Firstleaf has 100,000 members across the US.

Firstleaf

Main Differences Between Naked Wines and Firstleaf

What differentiates Naked Wines and Firstleaf is the selection of wine each offers, and the members hand it the selection. With Naked Wines, you actively support top-class, unique winemaking and pick and choose what you’d like delivered to your doorstep. Firstleaf takes a different approach. It has a team of tasters that sources its winning range and subscribers effectively select what works for them with a unique palate profile. In terms of location, both clubs operate in classic, well-known regions and with quality winemakers. There are no mega wineries and if there are a few large ones, they strive for that special touch. 

Main Benefits Overall Comparison 

Both clubs offer the finest labels. Membership with Naked Wines means you play a part in bringing amazing bottles into being while Firstleaf offers tailored personalization of shipments.

Wine Selection 

Naked Wines Main Benefits Overall

Naked Wines offers a one-of-a-kind subscription option where your monthly fee is pooled with those of fellow members and invested into the winemaking of small, artisanal vintners across the Old and New World. The club partners with about 150 wineries cutting out a costly supply chain. This treats your wallet to up to 60% in savings. Everyone wines because you get to enjoy skilfully-made wine you wouldn’t find anywhere else, and winemakers get a helping hand.

You can also keep in contact with your favorites via dedicated message areas where you can also compare notes on wines with fellow angels which offer transparency.

Firstleaf Main Benefits Overall 

Firstleaf’s calling card is its state-of-the-art tasting tech which guarantees your order will be customized so filled with the labels you enjoy most. Once you answer a short but delving quiz about our tastes, your data is crunched up and transformed into a shiny, new personal profile that the club matches with its vast inventory to tik all your boxes.

This club is very particular about hat it lets into its portfolio and your cases. Its tasting team tries about 10,000 labels each year and it only gives the green light to 2%.

Overall Winner

Firstleaf

You may also like the following comparison: Bright Cellars VS First Leaf

Subscription Plans

Naked Wines Wine Subscription Plans 

There’s only one subscription fee at Naked Wines. As a member, you deposit $40 into your “piggy bank” on a monthly basis and cash it in when you find some artisanal reds or whites that you like the look of. You get an impressive $100 off your first shipment and, with every case that follows, Naked Wines gifts you with a free bottle as a thank you for your support and to give your tastebuds something new to try.

If you don’t feel like cashing in your investment for one or two months, it’s no problem. Your membership is rolling, and you buy wines when a bottle piques your interest.

Firstleaf Wine Subscription Plans 

The standard Firstleaf subscription entitles you to six bottles every month. If you ever want to fill your shelves and double these up, you can do so and enjoy delivery of a dozen labels. What’s more, as a member of Firstleaf, you have a great opportunity of shopping in the club store and taking advantage of a 10% discount on extra bottles for your shipment if you’re just looking for one or two more.

Deliveries are monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly and you can change over to another frequency when it suits you – when you need extra stock around holidays for example.

Subscription Plans Winner:

Naked Wines

Pricing and Shipping

Naked Wines Pricing and Shipping 

Naked Wines works on the premise that the more you order, the more your wallet will thank you. If you cash in up to $100, you'll incur a shipping charge of $9.99. As soon as you go over $100, shipping is complimentary unless you live in Hawaii or Alaska where the cost is $130 and $70 per package, respectively.

You can be confident that your cases will arrive in good condition because Naked Wines only works with reputable companies like UPS, GSO, or FedEx. You can also take advantage of a tracking facility and request delivery changes.

Firstleaf Pricing and Shipping 

At Firstleaf you get six fine bottles for $15 each which works out at a jaw-dropping $90. You can also double up bottles which costs $159.95 plus tax and Firstleaf throws in free shipping.

Firstleaf offers flexibility with shipping allowing you to send your case to a holding location for up to a week if you don’t want it sent to your workplace and aren’t going to be at home. This service can be invaluable during the summer and winter months when you don’t want to leave your shipments outdoors where the extreme temperatures could damage the wines.

Pricing and Shipping Winner:

Firstleaf

Customer Service and Guarantee

Naked Wines Customer Service and Guarantee 

It’s easy to contact Naked Wines if you have a query or complaint. Phone, live automated chat, and email are at your disposal. With the latter, the club aims to reply within 24 hours Monday to Friday. The club also has a seamless way of dealing with any wine issues. If you aren’t satisfied with a wine, whether it just isn’t to your taste or arrives damaged or corked, Naked Wines will give you a full refund.

If you give a bottle a thumbs down on your personal rating page, the club will take care to never send you a similar wine in future. Of course, the opposite also applies so you’re covered!

Firstleaf Customer Service and Guarantee

You can email First Leaf’s customer service any time plus get in touch by phone during office hours seven days a week. This club also boasts a satisfaction guarantee that ensures you’re 100% happy with every single label you receive. If you don’t like a bottle or one arrives damaged, Firstleaf will give you credit to the value of the label you can use where you want in the club.

There are very rare cases where it can’t because of legal restrictions but this is not the norm.Your only obligation is to let the club know there’s a problem within 30 days of receipt of your case.

Customer Service and Guarantee Winner:

Naked Wines and Firstleaf draw in this area as they both put a lot of effort into customer satisfaction.

You may also like the following comparison: VineBox VS First Leaf

Cancellation Terms

Naked Wines Cancellation Terms  

Canceling your Naked Wines subscription is as easy as pie: you get in touch with its customer service by phone or email stating you’d like to close your membership. If you have outstanding credit in your “piggy bank”, the club will return it to you.

Naked Wines won’t want to let you go easily though as it cares enough to find out why you want to close your account. Before you go, it’ll remind you about the huge discount you enjoy on retail prices, its no-quibble guarantee, and the freedom you have to spend your investment when and as you want. You might even change your mind.

Firstleaf Cancellation Terms  

You can cancel your Firstleaf membership anytime by calling a dedicated number where they'll briefly discuss your options. The fact is, you may find it's not cancellation you’re after but simply tweaking your membership options. This could mean altering your delivery frequencies, your preferences, or bottle quantities in each shipment.

Of course, the club won’t stop you if you really want to say farewell – the customer service team just couldn’t sleep at night if it didn’t give you a few choices first as it might just be a matter of changing a few points to enhance your experience of the club.

Cancellation Terms Winner:

Again, both clubs are strong on their cancellation processes so they both come out on top.

Buy as a Gift

Naked Wines Wine Gifts 

You can’t buy a gift membership directly but there are other ways of giving a loved one some of the best wines on the block. It offers gift cards in $100, $50, $20, and $10 denominations which your loved one can use how they want at Naked Wines so they could take out a membership if the sum was high enough.

Alternatively, the club has a dedicated gift section that offers an array of service accessories and superb cases of wine where you can mix and match bottles. If you want to have a more personalized idea, get in touch as the club will work with you to make it a reality.

Firstleaf Gifts 

When you enjoy everything a wine club has to offer you want to spread the word. You can easily pick up a Firstleaf gift membership and even choose the preferences of your recipient via its cutting-edge algorithm for customization.

You also have the choice of purchasing a gift certificate for your friend or loved one so they can have the excitement of doing First Leaf’s palate profile quiz themselves and receiving a tailored case. If you know someone who may not value a full membership but loves a good bottle of wine once in a while, you can buy an electronic gift card.

Buy as a Gift Winner:

Firstleaf

Our Winner- Firstleaf!

Firstleaf

This is another difficult decision because both of these clubs offer amazing value to their subscribers but we’re veering towards Firstleaf this time. What's swung it is its state-of-the-art customization, award-winning portfolio, and gift options. It also offers a host of wine club deals like its free and flexible delivery on certain orders and its store discounts for members. Like Naked Wines, it works with artisanal producers but if you prefer to sit back rather than be hands-on, this club has your name on it.

First Leaf Full ReviewNaked Wines Review

Other Wine Subscription Options

Check out a whole host of other wine clubs for your perfect pick!