Founded by the Wall Street Journal, the WSJ Wine Club is an affordable wine club launched in 2008. Conceived just two years after its competitor, Plonk Wine Club features award-winning wines. Both the clubs showcase their own unique variety of membership plans for wine lovers in America.
Explore the accompanying perks and drawbacks of each wine club to determine the best match for your palate and pocket.
WSJ wine Membership Plans
Featuring two wine club memberships, wine lovers and sommeliers will find a wealth of information from the wine advisors included in this club.
Their wine plans include:
- Discovery Club: $69.99 every three months
- Premier Club: $259.99 every three months
Pros and Cons of WSJwine Plans
What makes the WSJ Wine Club worth trying?
- Gifts and Perks: From complimentary wines to wine glasses, members will receive many goodies when signing up for this club.
- Economical: WSJwine offers a wide variety of wines from around the world at cost-effective rates ranging from $6 to $12 per bottle.
- Huge Savings: Enjoy 20% of all future wine reorders when you sign up for any one of the plans.
- Award-Winning Wines: This wine club sends wines with no less than 90+ points.
- Flexibility: Whether you want to skip a month or cancel a shipment, this wine club makes it easy to change your membership plan.
Is the WSJ Wine Club right for you? Explore the drawbacks before deciding.
- Minimal Personalization: While this club doesn’t offer customization, you can swap bottles regardless of the wine plan you’re subscribed to.
- No Monthly Option: Wine shipments are sent every three months and oenophiles have no choice but to wait it out.
- Shipping Charge: There’s no free shipping from WSJwine and members agree to pay $19.99 for every shipment of 12 bottles.
Plonk Wine Club Membership Plans
Known for its all-natural wines, this wine club has a plan for every type of wine lover.
Their wine club plans are categorized as follows:
- Mixed Wines, White Wines and Red Wines: $110 to $285 based on total bottles
- Cabernet Club: $129.98 for two bottles
- Sauvignon Blanc Club: $129.98 for two bottles
- Pinot Noir Club: $129.98 for two bottles
Pros and Cons of Plonk Wine Club Plans
What are the advantages of signing up with Plonk?
- Largest Variety Of Wine Plans: If you split up the mixed wines, you get a total of six wine clubs, making it the largest selection around.
- Free Shipping: When you sign up, receive free shipping on all your orders via FedEx.
- Discounts On Reorders: Members receive up to 25% off when reordering wines.
- Perks: Get a complimentary wine bottle during membership renewals in addition to an industrial-grade corkscrew for first-time members.
- Free Copy Of Imbibe Magazine: Discover more about the world of wine every month with your shipment thanks to the inclusion of this free magazine.
Why not sign up for the Plonk? Explore a few of the drawbacks.
- Not So Flexible: Members can’t skip a month, but you can choose from monthly, quarterly or annual membership plans.
- Minimal Personalization: One of the downsides of signing up is the wine club doesn’t let you personalize the wine shipments, but you’re guaranteed to get award-winning wines.
- Expensive: The cost of creating eco-conscious wines comes with a higher price tag.
Verdict
WSJwine and Plonk Wine Club are wine clubs with different missions and visions. Plonk is known for its biodynamic wines while its close competitor trends for its affordable wines. Both offer excellent wines and ultimately you must choose the offering that’s right for your tastes and budget.
If you didn’t like the wines you received from either of the clubs, receive a full refund using the money-back guarantee on offer.